So i finished Shadow of the Wind

December 23rd, 2004 by badger

No, Rachel, you cannot read this. Go read it first. Danielle said that remaindered copy is still waiting for you down in Gonzales.

Gone yet?

Anyway…

It’s half of a great book. Once i made it past a crucial point, i realized that it was going to be a collapsed souffle. Zafon took it right up to the edge of being something grand, something cosmic, then ran a needle into it, and it collapsed into a much smaller, merely good book. It needed more Borges, and less Marquez. If it’s to be a book hung upon the premise of peculiar, haunting books drawn from the fervored imagination of an enigmatic author, jettisoning the mystery of books for a tangled web of earthly human passions is just not a change in pace i care to follow.

I’d recommend the book to anyone who wants a good diversion. Otherwise, i feel it betrayed itself, too proud to embrace its own pulp core and too lazy to reach for more.

One Response to “So i finished Shadow of the Wind

  1. Rachel says:

    Aye, captain! I hope to pick up a copy soon.

Leave a Reply